For the Ladies: How do I get her back?


    Question for the ladies:

    I’ve been talking with a woman, and both of us like each other a lot (we did, at least). But I said something, that she took in the total opposite way that I intended, and now won’t speak to me. Here’s the timeline.

    At the beginning of the week, we were talking on the phone. I’m a deep thinker, and love having theoretical discussions about subjects, outside of their personal application. So I asked her what she thought about a particular viewpoint, that was contrary to the one she holds. I did this purely from a desire to spark a discussion, and see if we could learn more about the subject together. I played devil’s advocate when she made particular assertions, not in an aggressive way, but merely asking her what she thought about the counter-point. She, being very passionate about the issue, took it as me taking the opposite position. I’m not going to specify precisely what the issue is, but suffice to say that it’s a very important, very sensitive theological issue.

    The strange thing, is that she didn’t react negatively right away. We got together for a date two days later, and I thought we were at a “transition point” in our relationship. I was ready to progress things, so I asked her how she felt about me, and the relationship between us. She said that she liked me as much as ever, and that her feelings had only grown. That she wanted things to work out between us.

    Shortly after said date, she sends me a text, telling me it’s over. As the reason, she gives me the issue I already described above. And tells me that I clearly have no respect for her beliefs, or her convictions, because I sought to invalidate them. When that was never ever my intent. I just wanted to have a discussion, and never meant to attack her point of view.

    So, needless to say, her text nearly gave me a heart attack. And I’ve frantically been trying to explain, but she just responded by saying her feelings for me are gone, as a result of my disrespect towards her convictions. And asked me to stop contacting her.

    How do I get through to her, and win her back? What can I do to revive the feelings that were there, before this misunderstanding took place?

    Queen bed Asked on July 5, 2019 in SINGLE.
    Add Comment
    15 Answer(s)

      She lied to you during the date? If so then how do you know if she ever did have feelings for you?

      Fell out of ... Answered on July 5, 2019.

      No, I don’t think she lied. She was very affectionate during the date. So unless she’s a class actor, and grade A liar, she still felt things for me while we were out.

      It’s after I left, that something happened, or she talked to someone about what happened, or something. At which point she got to thinking about the things I said, and her emotions took a negative turn.

      on July 5, 2019.
      Add Comment

        Sorry you’re going through this. She might just need space for a few days. If she really loves you, she’ll come around and try to understand.

        If she’s the type for emails, I would say, write and explain what you were doing, and make a thorough explanation of your real view. I’m the type to write out really long emails and that’s the kind of thing I would look for.

        When people play devil’s advocate, then later say they weren’t serious, it takes a while for me to be convinced they really do believe what they say they believe. So if you can be just as passionate about that belief as she is (“preaching it”) hopefully she’ll see that it comes from your heart.

        So if you send her a message like I described (maybe a couple days from now), ask her out and say you want to talk with her.  If she’s willing to see you in person, that’s ideal because she can see your facial expressions to see you’re sincere.

        It would be a bonus if you could show what you believe on social media (if you have facebook, etc.). Publicly sharing your beliefs would give her another reason to believe you.

        Queen bed Answered on July 5, 2019.

        Ok, I just realized that you said she asked you to stop contacting her. In that case it’s best to let her take the next step, but you can prepare for what to say, during this time.

        God is able to lead you back together! I’m sure He is already working in her heart.

        on July 6, 2019.
        Add Comment

          And show you are truly sorry for hurting her feelings. That is really important  to a woman! Show your love for her whatever way you can. 

          Praying for God’s will and healing in your relationship!

          Queen bed Answered on July 5, 2019.
          Add Comment
            Best answer

            Is this the same girl you posted about last month? The one that you were “talking to” that was a non-virgin?

            It sounds as though you are not compatible, so why push it? Not everyone enjoys theoretical discussions and debate, which seems like something that you like to pursue. Bottom line, if a woman asks you to not contact her again, you do not contact her again. Otherwise, you are a stalker.

            On the floor Answered on July 6, 2019.

            No, that ended. New girl, (was) much more promising.

            She lives with her parents, and her mother liked me. Her and her mother are really close, so I’ve been talking to her mom about what happened, in the hope that she can help me open up a dialogue.

            on July 6, 2019.

            I’m getting the feeling that you are both young and that when you say you are “talking to” this girl or that, this is through text message or online? I don’t know if you are doing this with multiple girls at the same time, or if this new girl you are referring to in this post is someone you’ve been communicating with for less than a month? Was this a first date (where you got together in person to do something together)?

            “Talking to” someone for less than a month isn’t really a relationship. I’m hoping that others here will realize that and not encourage you to keep pursuing this young lady.

            on July 8, 2019.
            Add Comment

              You asked for answers from the ladies, and I most definitely don’t fit that description, but I may have a little bit to offer.

              You didn’t say what the subject of the conversation was about, but from what you are saying, her reaction is less about you having differing views, than the way you made her feel. Playing devils advocate is one thing, but trampling on her feelings in the process is something else entirely. It sounds like that is how she felt about the interaction.

              First of all, forgive me for saying this so bluntly, but it was a stupid thing to do at this stage of your relationship. Regardless of how you felt about the subject, if she perceived you were trying to “change her mind” about something she has deep convictions about, then it likely came across as you trying to change her to suit you(you aren’t quite what I am looking for, but with some minor adjustments”.

              My wife and I have reached a point where we are mostly in agreement in most subjects, but we haven’t always been. One thing I am certain of is that I have never convinced her of anything, but I have occasionally caused damage in the relationship when I tried. A good rule to follow would be “dialogue, not debate”.

              I don’t know how this will help you moving forward, but rather than focusing on whatever the subject was, it would probably be helpful for you to apologize for how you made her feel, rather than spending more time on the subject itself.

              On the floor Answered on July 6, 2019.
              Add Comment

                The first thing that comes to mind is, “Who breaks up in a text message?” Do you really want someone who would do that to you?

                Second, it sounds like she definitely has had some help in deciding that you don’t respect her beliefs or convictions and that you seek to invalidate them, if she didn’t think that immediately. She may even think she came to the conclusion based on reflection alone, but have you considered whether there were any other reasons she might have felt she had to end the budding relationship. Could she have just found the “debate” to be a convenient excuse?

                Third, I have always wondered about the phrase “devil’s advocate”.  It literally means ADVOCATE–argue for, defend, take the side of THE DEVIL, you know, Satan, the evil one. Why do people think it is merely a game to argue the Devil’s point of view and wonder why it upsets people when they do?  Maybe a better way to take a discussion deeper would be to ask open-ended questions like, “Why do you think that? Would it make a difference if… How did you come to that opinion? I’ve heard this opposite opinion; can you help me understand what’s wrong with it?” Ask her to help you learn and understand instead of expecting her to defend her view against a facetious attack.

                Fourth, read your question above again and note your pronouns and verbs. Wherever you use “I” the verb is one of innocent intent, well-meaning, misunderstood actions. Whenever you use “she” the verbs are to say she misunderstood, she took it wrong, she won’t speak, she reacted negatively, she broke up in a mean way, she won’t listen,  she refuses your explanation and cut off contact.  In other words, “I’m” the victim, “she’s” the one behaving badly. Have you truly taken full responsibility in your heart for hurting her and damaging the growing relationship?

                It strikes me that you should find a strong believer, a brother in Christ, in whom you can confide and on whom you can depend for good advice and example. In contemplating what you said about the other girl, and now this one, I wonder if you have some misconceptions about how relationships are supposed to work? I’m not trying to be harsh; it’s just something to consider.

                God Bless your efforts to find love!! I’ll be praying for you!

                Under the stars Answered on July 6, 2019.

                Very insightful advice and analysis Duchess!

                on July 6, 2019.
                Add Comment


                  Who breaks up in a text? A panicking girl, who’s never been in a relationship before, that doesn’t want to get hurt. Your point is entirely valid, and I’m definitely not feeling very loved by her handling of the situation. But she’s never done this before.

                  It could be. But it’s a highly religious household, passionate about scripture. So I’m inclined to believe she wouldn’t lie to me. Though there have been some inconsistencies between her “objections”, and what her mother has told me. Not complete differences, but some stuff.

                  Devil’s advocate was just the way in which I tried to communicate the idea to you guys. What I said to her, was something like “Hey, I was thinking about such-and-such today, and this verse came to mind. Have you ever thought about how the implication here would effect such-and-such? Do you think that’s what it means?”

                  I don’t know if I’ve taken full responsibility, but I sure hope so. Even though the intents of my heart have been completely mistaken by her, I’m truly sorry for my part. Though I don’t believe I did anything “wrong”, with regard to this misunderstanding. I may have worded something poorly, but that’s an honest mistake. Something I’d expect her to discuss with me, not blow up on me about.

                  I don’t confide in my friends about girls I meet, as I don’t want them to be privy to our struggles, and her personal issues, if the girl becomes a part of my life. It would be a violation of our privacy as a couple, and make her feel exposed to those around her.

                  Queen bed Answered on July 6, 2019.
                  Add Comment


                    I was thinking about sending her a handwritten note, with her favorite chocolate bar, and some flowers. Though if what she said is true, and all her feelings for me are gone, I don’t know if it will do much good :/

                    I’ve heard it said that when a woman is done, she’s done. Their emotions only go one way. Is that true?

                    Queen bed Answered on July 6, 2019.
                    Add Comment

                      She asked you to stop contacting her. I know you’ll find it difficult, but that means she wants to be left alone.

                      Chasing after her to try and win her back is likely to push her further away ( I speak from personal experience).


                      Fell out of ... Answered on July 7, 2019.
                      Add Comment

                        @ David

                        That’s not something I can do. I care, so I’m going to fight for her. If that turns her off, then I’m not the one for her.

                        Queen bed Answered on July 7, 2019.

                        bravo on your commitment to follow thru. I would just advise you to go slow, almost to the point of starting over.

                        I would like to make the point that fighting for someone can work. I fought for my wife and won her back. Had I remained the same person who lost her, that would not have happened. I am not advocating changing for someone else, in my case, and probably in every case, we can and should be better than we were. I would start by re thinking your assertion that you didn’t do anything wrong. It would appear that you hirt the object of your affections. You can claim miscommunication, mistake intentions, or whatever you like, but that doesn’t really mend hearts. Humility and taking responsibility for your actions sometimes does.

                        You are obviously free to pursue any path you like, and you are to be commended for seeking counsel. Are you willing to follow it?

                        Duchess gave you some things to think about, most notably in her 4th paragraph. Have you considered them?

                        on July 7, 2019.
                        Add Comment

                        Your Answer

                        By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.